We begin with twelve men, of all ages and from all areas of our fine nation. I'll be somewhat brief this week as it was challenging to write my notes because of the rapid pace of this evening's show.
In the words of the great Randy Jackson, so check it:
01 - David Hernandez - Strong vocal. I liked the selection.
02 - Chikezie - Check out that gear! He rocked it. Big vocal.
03 - David Cook - I like this guy a lot. He mixed it up. The hair straightener did not work for me.
04 - Jason Yeager - Ok, I am going to go there. (Yes, this early in the season.) Call me conservative, but I don't dig the hair. It should be one color. Song selection - ok. It was safe. It was a nice performance.
05 - Robbie Carrico - This guy is cool. His song selection was just ok, but the performance was solid.
06 - David Archuleta - I love this kid. He's awesome. FUN song. He's super.
07 - Danny Noriega - Good performance, fun song, I am just not a fan. I don't like the attitude.
08 - Luke Menard - He sounds like Kenny Loggins. (Thank you, Paula, for agreeing.) It was difficult to hear him, and I thought it was safe.
09 - Colton Berry - Daughtry sang this the week he got kicked off. (You all still remember that week, right? I threw things, I yelled at the TV, I tried to explain how stupid America is to Mr. Watson on the phone, I protested...you get the picture.) This kid is good too. He is definitely a performer.
10 - Garrett Haley - Not at all what I expected, but I also think this was the first I saw of him. Boring selection. I won't remember this performance without my Idol notebook. Simon was WAY harsh!
11 - Jason Castro - Not sure at all. I just don't have an opinion yet.
12 - Michael Johns - Seriously, let's just put him in the top 12 now. Bring it!
Summary
- In - Michael Johns, David Archuletta
- Cool - Robby Carrico, David Cook
- Solid - David Hernandez, Chikezie, Colton Berry
- Unsure - Jason Castro
- Potential Chopping Block - Garrett Haley, Jason Yeager, Danny Noriega, Luke Menard
2 comments:
Here are my top 6 guys...we'll see if I'm right. I know, that is doubtful.
In no particular order:
1. Michael Johns
2. David Cook
3. Jason Castro
4. David Archuleta
5. David Hernandez
6. Chikezie
Only time will tell....
loved Jason Castro, David Cook and Michael Johns. Luke is cute to look at but that is about it. Danny Noriega and Garrett Haley- Two Words "A MESS"! - Mel
Post a Comment